Shop 20 of the Highest-Rated, Bestselling Shoes From Old Navy

If you think you have to splurge to find shoes that are both fashion-forward and comfortable, prepare to be pleasantly surprised by the extensive range of options available at Old Navy. The affordably priced retailer has everything, from stylish espadrilles and dressy heels to slip-on sandals and comfortable sneakers for walking. To simplify your shoe-shopping experience, we’ve meticulously sifted through online reviews, handpicked our favorite styles, and even tested several pairs ourselves to curate a list of must-have shoes from Old Navy’s expansive selection.

Whether you’re seeking a timeless staple or experimenting with trendy styles without breaking the bank, we’ve got you covered. Our curated selection features a mix of editor-loved bestsellers and highly-rated silhouettes, including our very own honest reviews. With significant markdowns, some even priced under $10, the combination of quality and affordability makes these options a smart investment. Keep scrolling to shop the 20 best Old Navy shoes to discover your new favorite pair for this season and beyond.